Court Rejects Claim for Share When Couple Break Up


Court rejects claim for share when couple break upWhen a couple break up, the division of the assets they own is often problematic, whether they are married or not.

In a recent case, the Court of Appeal was asked to consider the appropriate division of assets when an unmarried couple broke up after being together on and off for more than a decade.

The couple began living together in 1992, then separated in 1995. In 2001, they got back together, living in the man’s house until 2002, when they bought another property in joint names in which they lived until it was sold in 2007. The man was a property developer. In 2002, he formed a company which bought and sold several properties over the years. In addition, he sometimes purchased development properties in his own name. One such was transferred to the company and later sold at a profit in excess of £400,000.

When the couple broke up, the female partner claimed that the true ownership status of all the properties they had acquired (there were three remaining by this time) was equal and that she had been promised that she owned a half share in all of them, the purchases having been structured as they were merely in order to avoid unpalatable tax consequences.

Fatal to her claim with regard to shared ownership of the properties owned by the company was the Court’s finding that (in effect) she had not had any promise made to her by the company which was enforceable against it. Furthermore, she had done nothing to her detriment which could ‘Justify the creation of a good claim in equity against the company’.

The case illustrates how important it is to prepare one’s claim carefully when bringing proceedings and also to ensure that ‘casual’ promises are turned into legally binding ones. In this case, the male partner’s promise on his own behalf did not bind the company.

Couples who cohabit should consider making a Living Together Agreement and taking steps to ensure that any significant transactions are properly documented in legal form. Contact us for advice.

We offer fixed fees, and give excellent value.

We operate a free and confidential 24 hour email service. Just click on [email protected] or, during office hours there is a free and confidential legal helpline 020 7381 8111.