CONGRATULATIONS, IT’S A… FIGMENT


A cautionary tale for fathers – or rather, for those who turn out not to be

Most men who are told they are about to become a father experience some mixture of joy,
terror and a sudden interest in the price of pushchairs. Very few think to ask for proof that the
baby actually exists. After a remarkable High Court case reported in The Times this month,
perhaps a few more should.

Mrs Justice Judd has found that a woman faked not one but two births, and that over the years
her former partner sent her something in the region of £30,000 to support her and two
children who were never there. The judgment was handed down in February but has only just
been published, with the parties anonymised as “John” and “Jane”.

Shiloh Rose, 5lb 9oz

John and Jane met at the start of the pandemic. He kept his own home but spent much of his
time at hers. In 2022 Jane announced she was pregnant and sent him an ultrasound image.
John later told the court that when he touched her stomach “it was hard, like a pregnant
stomach”.

Before the due date, the couple argued and Jane told the police that John had assaulted her.
He was arrested. Two days later, John’s stepfather received a cheerful message: “She’s here
everybody! Shiloh Rose 5lb 9oz 1.44am.” John’s mother was sent a voice note in the small
hours with a baby crying in the background. Photographs of a little girl followed over the
coming months.

There was, however, always a reason why John could not see his daughter. She was being
looked after by relatives. Social services were involved. Social workers had said he was not
allowed contact. And yet the couple reconciled for a time, and the photographs kept coming.

And then there were two

In 2024 Jane announced a second pregnancy. John’s mother saw her and later told the court
she was “visibly pregnant”. The relationship ended for good, but that same month Jane
messaged John’s mother to say she had given birth to a boy, Aryeh, and that social services
would support her with anything she needed. More photographs arrived. Shortly afterwards
Jane reported John to the police for allegedly trying to break into her house. He was arrested
again; the charges were dropped.

Throughout all this John kept sending money. He carried on even after Jane remarked, at one
point, that she had “sold the children for £500” – a line which, in hindsight, might have
prompted a few questions.

The penny drops

Eventually John became worried about what had happened to his children and made enquiries
of the local authority and the police. In October 2024 he applied to the court to find out where
they were and for parental responsibility. Jane responded by seeking a non-molestation order
against him, alleging abuse.

It was at a hearing on that application that Jane’s own lawyer told the judge that the couple
did not, in fact, have any children together. Jane’s explanation was that she had miscarried
twice. She later suggested the deceit had been her adult daughter’s partner’s idea.
John, to his credit or perhaps his misfortune, did not at first accept this. He and his mother
had both seen her pregnant. But there were no local authority records, no police records about
the children, and no record of Jane receiving any antenatal care. The judge found that John
had been “the victim of a sustained and elaborate campaign of deceit”, and added that it was
cruel, leading a man and his mother to believe they had children and grandchildren. She did
not reach a conclusion on Jane’s motive, though she noted that financial fraud was “a
possibility” given the considerable sums she had received.

A few words of advice

Cases like this are rare, and nobody should read it as licence to treat every expectant mother
with suspicion. Miscarriage is real and painful, and most people announcing a pregnancy are
simply telling the truth. But if you are being asked to pay for a child you have never been
allowed to meet, a little healthy scepticism is not unkind. A few practical points:

First, a real baby leaves a paper trail. Every birth in England and Wales must be registered
within 42 days, and if you are not married to the mother you can ask to be named on the birth
certificate. A short birth certificate costs very little and settles the question of existence at a
stroke.

Second, if you doubt that you are the father, ask for a DNA test. If you are being kept away,
the court can direct one as part of any application you make.

Third, pay maintenance through the proper channels. The Child Maintenance Service will
want to know who the child is before it calculates anything. Regular bank transfers on the
strength of photographs sent by text message are, as John discovered, a less reliable system.

Fourth, if you are being told that social services or the police are involved and that this is why
you cannot see the child, that is something you can check. John eventually did – but only
after years of paying.

Finally, if you find yourself facing a non-molestation application or a police complaint at the
same moment you start asking awkward questions, take legal advice early. Allegations of that
kind are serious and must be dealt with properly, whatever their origin.

Not quite a happy ending

John has the satisfaction of a High Court finding that he was deceived. What he does not have
is his £30,000, or the two children he and his mother had spent years believing in. Whether
Jane will face any further consequences remains to be seen.

The moral of the story? Love may be blind, but it should at least ask to see the birth

certificate.

With acknowledgement to Jonathan Ames’s report in The Times, 4 October 2026.
Rodney Hylton-Potts
November 2026